Since General Fezi, commander-in-chief of the Caucasian armies, was at this time engaged in bloody battles in the southern regions of Daghestan and Shamil's headquarters was very far from this region, the task of arranging this historic and important meeting was given to General Klüge von Klugenau. This Muscovite general, a German of Austrian origin, had won great fame for his courage and severity in the Caucasian wars of invasion, and had lost his right leg to a Daghestani cannonball during the capture of the fortress of Zakatal by the Russians.

General Klugenau, who in his long and bloody years of experience in the Caucasus had come to know the Caucasian spirit and self-sacrifice very closely, knew well that the mediating task given to him of arranging the meeting between the Tsar and Shamil would end in failure. But what could he do, since the Emperor was extremely insistent on this will and decision of his.

The general, who had learned Caucasian customs and tribal traditions, decided, in order to accomplish this delicate task, to resort to the mediation and help of the Karanay beks, who were friends of the Russians and neighbours of Shamil. He gave these beks a letter written in his own hand to be delivered to Sheikh Shamil. The Karanay beks brought this letter and handed it to Shamil at his temporary and secret headquarters near the village of Gimry where he had been born and raised. Shamil, who considered those who had sold themselves to the enemy more dangerous than the Tsar and his armies, could not bear, or even permit, these bloodless and honourless beks to sit in his presence. He lowered his hate-filled eyes to the ground and, in a few words forced out from between his lips:

-Go and tell your general: if he has any business to discuss with us, these free mountains, where the Tsar and his decrees have no sway, are open to every guest who comes in friendship. Let him not be afraid, let him come! he muttered angrily.

Following this reply, on the 18th of September 1837 a historic meeting took place near the Sulak river, at a locality in the north of Daghestan close to Chechnya.

Tsar Nicholas I's extraordinary envoy, General Klüge von Klugenau, accompanied by Colonel Yevdokimov, the officers of his suite and an interpreter, came to Shamil's headquarters escorted by thirty Don Cossack guards.

Sheikh Shamil came out to meet this detachment with a splendid and imposing escort formed by his naibs (commanders) and two hundred select Caucasian horsemen. These two detachments of eternal enemies, whose whole lives had been spent cutting each other's throats, when they came face to face looked long at one another in a deathly silence with blood-suffused eyes. As soon as General Klüge recognised Shamil by his tall, stately figure, he reined in his horse and leapt to the ground with an agility unexpected of his crippled leg. At a sharp signal from the general, the Don Cossacks turned their horses' heads and began to fall back as if trampling one another. In response to this move of the general, Shamil too left his guards behind and advanced slowly between three naibs, and, approaching the edge of a yamchi spread on the ground, waited for his guest with his eyes on the ground and his lips continually occupied in prayer to his God.

Shamil would receive on this Caucasian yamchi the proud and despotic envoy of His Majesty Nicholas I, protector of the Orthodox and Tsar of the Russians, and would in this way convey that he attached no value whatever to this historic meeting. General Klüge von Klugenau, who was in any case convinced that nothing would come of this meeting, summoning all his composure and mastering his anger, saluted the lion of the free and impassable mountains with the reverence due to a sovereign.

After the Tsar's general had introduced to Shamil one by one his chief of staff, Colonel Yevdokimov, and the officers of his suite, Shamil in turn introduced to the general one by one his naibs, each of whom bore the memories of forty victories and who were the renowned heroes of the Caucasian wars.

Shamil showed a place on one edge of the yamchi to this famous Tsarist general, whom he had brought to his knees in many battles and whose leg he had blown off in one battle with a cannonball of vengeance. The general, hesitantly and as if finding it strange, all but perched on this yamchi patched in forty places with pieces of leather.

The general had been handed a talismanic copy of a speech, drawn up with deep attention and care and composed with much calculation and study. Von Klugenau, summoning all his eloquence, began to deliver this ode-like speech in the name of Tsar Nicholas I. This devilishly contrived speech, which went on and on with dazzling promises and splendid offers that whipped up ambition, was translated word for word to Shamil by the general's interpreter.

According to this speech, the Emperor wished to place a royal crown on the head of Sheikh Shamil, whose heroism he admired, whose patriotism he respected, and in whose unbending power he had come to believe through a thousand and one bloody experiences.

All the treasures of the Tsardom and the peerless sources of wealth of the Caucasus would be spread beneath Shamil's feet. In return for all these unattainable worldly blessings, all the Tsar asked of Shamil would be no more than his friendship and loyalty. Yet the true meaning of this hypocritical speech, which sought to catch Shamil with a golden lasso, was this: "O Shamil! Put an end now to these endless and exhausting struggles. What will you gain from these hopeless wars that file away your life and never show you the face of ease and peace? Sell your homeland, sell your honour, trample your oath underfoot and surrender to the Tsar.

Instead of a turban and kalpak you will wear pearl-studded crowns on your head; instead of this shabby yamchi you will sit on emerald thrones. Gold and jewels will flow like rivers from your palaces, and the whole world will recognise and confirm the sovereignty over the Caucasus of you and of your most distant descendants after you. On the face of the earth you will have no master other than the Tsar, the greatest power after God."