As the general finished his speech in great excitement, he set about observing, in even greater excitement, the effect this speech had left on Shamil. Shamil shook himself as if waking from a frightening dream and, rising to his feet as though he had heard nothing at all:

My prayer time is passing! he muttered angrily, and walked like a terrible shadow towards where his guards stood. Shamil's comrades in arms observed in amazement that never once in their lives had they encountered the terrible expression of hatred and wrath that covered the leader's calm eyes at that moment, and that even in the fiercest moments of battle he had never lost his composure to such a degree.

Shamil, performing his prayer on virgin grass greener than the Tsar's emeralds and brighter than his treasures, his back turned to his enemies and his face to his God, opened his palms in supplication and asked God for patience and calm towards this disrespectful envoy of the Tsar who had dared to make him so base an offer. In the difficult moments of the Caucasian wars, when he had to make great and daring decisions, this lion of Daghestan, who never fell into lasso or trap, would hasten into the presence of God and make his most fitting decisions in this great court of right and wisdom.

The answer he would give today to the envoy whom the proud and mighty Russian Tsar, ruler of a fifth of the world, had sent right to his feet could create new and bloodier scenes in the destiny of the Caucasus. If he bowed to the Tsar's deceitful offers, homeland and honour would be destroyed, and the rearing sacred revolution would kneel. A harsh, flat refusal could drown the Caucasus anew in blood and fire. In this very delicate situation, God gave inspiration to His heroic servant. Drawing his last and final decision from this inspiration, Shamil turned to the gold-braided and corded servants of the Tsar who squatted on that yamchi and clung to the soil of the homeland like the scab of a wound, and thundered in a voice that poured forth the unquenchable rancour of the whole Caucasus:

"- General! Go to that Nicholas and tell him: if he himself were before me at this moment in your place and had the courage to make these wretched offers in person, my first and last answer to him would be given by this whip of mine."

General Klüge von Klugenau started violently at this utterly unexpected answer and turned pale as a sheet. He was trembling all over with rage and his teeth were chattering. Shamil continued fearlessly and without ceremony: "-Tell him! Unless this peerless faith in victory, rooted in the hearts of this flock of heroes at whose head I stand, is torn out by the roots, no force will be able to prevent me from defending this blessed homeland inch by inch, to its last mountain, its last village and its very last piece of rock, until everyone, from my youngest warriors to my oldest naibs, is left with but a single bullet and a single arm.

Even if you put all my children and family to the sword for this cause, even if you dry up my last progeny, even if you annihilate my very last murid, I shall still fight on alone to my last breath. This is my last answer, General: I do not recognise Nicholas!..." As soon as he finished speaking, Shamil rose abruptly to show that there was nothing more to discuss and that this meeting was over. The general and his suite had perforce risen as well. As this arrogant envoy of the Tsar, who had been put in a very bad position before his master, prepared to depart, Shamil, after hesitating for a moment about shaking the hand of this enemy of religion and homeland, reflected that this man, who was a guest in his own headquarters, was at the same time nothing but a servant under orders. Besides, according to the noble tradition of Turkish warriorhood, no harm must come to an envoy.

He saw no objection to extending his hand to the general as a guest and an envoy. But at that very moment an imposing shadow appeared at Shamil's side, seized his wrist, and roared in a voice that shook the surroundings like a wounded lion: "Imam: do not touch the infidel with your hand, you will be defiled!" This roaring lion was the famous Surkhay Khan of Akhulgo, one of Shamil's most beloved and trusted naibs.

The general, who had knowingly swallowed many insults for the sake of this meeting, could bear it no longer; in his rage, not even finding time to grab his weapon, he raised the crutch that carried his crippled body and lunged at Surkhay Khan. Surkhay Khan was in any case on the alert. The general's raising of his crutch and Surkhay's drawing of his kinjal from its sheath happened in the same instant. The hands of the two hundred horsemen behind Shamil also went in an instant to the silver hilts of their swords.

The news of this humiliation suffered by General Klüge von Klugenau reached the Tsar's Palace with lightning speed. So as not to waste the pompous and costly travel preparations Nicholas I had made to see and capture Shamil, another attempt at a meeting was made with Shamil, this time with a letter from General Fezi, commander-in-chief of the Caucasian armies. Shamil did not hesitate for a moment to respond to this splendid letter too with a short and sharp refusal. Shamil's historic reply, still preserved in the Caucasian military archives in Petersburg, then the Russian capital, reads exactly as follows: Gimry, 28 September 1837. I, Shamil, the humblest of the warriors who have taken up arms for the freedom of the Caucasus, am a Muslim true in heart and word who has vowed not to sacrifice God's protection to the lordship of tsars. I had told General Klüge again and again, in a language he could understand, that I do not recognise Tsar Nicholas I and that his will has no sway in these rugged mountains. As if these words had been spoken to a stone, you still keep inviting me to Tiflis to meet the Tsar.

With this letter of mine I inform you for the last time that I will never accept this invitation. Even if I knew that for this my mortal body would be hacked to pieces and that not one stone would be left upon another in this homeland soil against which I set my back, I would never change this final decision of mine. My answer consists of this alone. Let it thus be known to Nicholas and his slaves. Upon this harsh reply of Shamil, which dashed all the Russian Tsar's hopes regarding the Caucasus, the palace flew into a fury. When the Tsar became thoroughly convinced that there was no other way than to bring Sheikh Shamil, whom he could not bring under control by politics and trickery, to submission by the might and terror of his armies, he decided to leave the word once again to the fortune of arms.

Tsar Nicholas I had definitively resolved to eliminate, whatever the cost, Shamil, who had insulted his envoys, driven his most famous generals from his presence, and finally treated him as nothing.

He at once placed a famous commander named General Golovin at the head of the Caucasian armies, and ordered this general, before anything else, to prepare a terrible plan of invasion and revenge.

According to this plan, three armies would move against the Caucasus at once: one of these armies would trample Circassia and descend to the Black Sea, the second would bring the tribes of the upper Samur into submission, and the third, the important army, would conquer Chechnya and Daghestan. General Grabbe had taken over the command of the third army of this plan, which was aimed directly at Shamil's person and his centre of activity. While this extremely secret invasion preparation advanced with great speed, Sheikh Shamil, who had put the Tsar's treasuries and armies to such pains, suddenly vanished, leaving neither sound nor trace.

This strange and mysterious event, instead of pleasing Tsar Nicholas, threw him into utter alarm. This sudden silence of Shamil seemed more distressing to the palace than the moments of crisis when he had made the Tsar's armies vomit blood. For the Tsar knew better than anyone that it was inconceivable that Shamil, in love with God and with victory, would withdraw from the war or turn his face away from the enemy.

Along with the Tsar, all enemies great and small knew well that this sudden silence and disappearance of Shamil could mean nothing other than gathering momentum to prepare for a new and even more terrible onslaught.