In the Bulgarian-Greek church question (1840–1872) two important figures emerged. One of them was Neofit Hilendarski Bozveli, the other Ilarion Makariopolski. When Neofit Hilendarski came to Istanbul in the spring of 1839, he gave an influential speech to the Bulgarian community of Istanbul, which by then had become Hellenized, and was the first to put forward the idea of rising up against the Greek Patriarchate of the Phanar, but he did not live long enough to see the struggle end in victory. Ilarion Makariopolski, on the other hand, became the pioneer of the struggle and, although he was sent into exile, saw his ideal realized together with his other comrades in the struggle, both from the clergy and from the people. The Bulgarian church fought as a church with a tradition of performing its own distinctive rites and tried never to make any concession on this matter. However, although it had strived from its foundation for the ideal of acquiring a national identity, after Bulgaria came under the rule of the Ottoman Empire, and especially after the conquest of Istanbul, the Greek Patriarchate of the Phanar abused the privileges granted to it by Sultan Mehmed the Conqueror on which it relied. In order to realize the "Megali Idea", the Patriarchate worked in an ever-increasing manner to eliminate Bulgarianness, Bulgarian nationalism and the Bulgarian language, and as a result of these efforts it succeeded in making even the Bulgarians accept that the use of the word Bulgarian was shameful.

On his return at the beginning of 1845 from his exiles in Tarnovo, Hilendar, Zograf and Dionysiou, to which he had gone as a result of the intrigues of the Greek Patriarchate, Neofit Hilendarski found a ground more favorable for development compared with the period five years earlier, for the following reasons:

1 - The awakening of the Bulgarians, despite the Hellenist propaganda of the Greek Patriarchate of the Phanar that kept them under oppression, as a result of the birth of the concept of "nation" in Europe in the light of the French Revolution and of the works of Paisiy Hilendarski reflecting that the Bulgarians were a great and separate nation in history;

2 - The granting of new rights to the nations under the rule of the Ottoman State by the Gülhane Hatt-ı Hümayun of 1839, and their confirmation by a new Hatt-ı Hümayun;

3 - The great strides made by the Bulgarian colony in Istanbul in both intellectual and material development

4 - The Bulgarian demands receiving the support of the Pole Michał Czajkowski, who served in the Ottoman army under the name Sadık Pasha:

5 - Neofit Hilendarski meeting again in Istanbul with Stoyan Mihailovski, whom he had come to know while in exile, who later bore the title of Metropolitan of Tarnovo.

Neofit Hilendarski and Stoyan Mihailovski, who began to work in such an environment, submitted a petition of complaint to the Sublime Porte, stating that they were being forced by the Greek Patriarchate of the Phanar to use Greek as the language of the liturgy and of instruction in churches and schools, and moreover that, because of the greed of the bishops, money was being collected for the Patriarchate rightly or wrongly, and that this situation was causing extreme discontent in the Bulgarian community; they asked the Ottoman government to protect the Bulgarians. The most important points of this petition were as follows:

1) That the tax of 7,000,000 kuruş collected by the Greek Patriarchate of the Phanar, on what grounds it was assessed being unknown to the Bulgarians, should not be paid by the Bulgarian eparchies:

2) That in places inhabited by Bulgarians, Bulgarian bishops should be appointed, providing education that would address the congregation in its mother tongue:

3) That the salaries of the bishops from the eparchies and the fees they would receive during all kinds of non-liturgical duties should be fixed:

4) That 3 Bulgarian bishops should sit as full members of the Holy Synod at the Greek Patriarchate of the Phanar, that they should be elected by the Bulgarian community, and that they could be removed from office only at the wish of the community and by order of the Sublime Porte;

5) That there should be four Bulgarian civilian representatives in Istanbul representing the Bulgarian Community before the Ottoman government and voicing the demands of the Bulgarian community. At the same time Ilarion, in a separate memorandum he wrote in French, informed Grand Vizier Mustafa Reşid Pasha of the persecutions inflicted on the Bulgarian community. In this memorandum Ilarion described in bitter terms how the Greeks wished to assimilate and wipe out the Bulgarian race in order to realize their "Megali Idea".

He also asked for the help of the Sublime Porte regarding these demands of the Bulgarians, the separation of the church administration function that was in their hands, and the Bulgarians' founding of a church in Istanbul. Mustafa Reşid Pasha received these requests of the Istanbul Bulgarians with great understanding and ordered the Greek Patriarchate of the Phanar to reach a decision on the matter. This order put the Greek Patriarchate of the Phanar in a difficult position, and its machinery of intrigue immediately began to work. To save the situation, a rumor was deliberately spread that Neofit Hilendarski and Ilarion were in contact with Polish and Russian émigrés and that they were harmful to the country. On the strength of this rumor the Patriarchate succeeded in obtaining from the Ottoman administration an order for Neofit Hilendarski and Ilarion to be arrested and exiled to Mount Athos. Some time after this event, the Patriarchate's kavasses together with gendarmes seized Neofit as he was walking in the street, and then Ilarion, who had been summoned to the Patriarchate on the pretext that a letter needed to be written in Slavonic, was also arrested. Neofit and Ilarion were taken to Büyükada and confined in the present-day Monastery of Aya Yorgi at the place also known as Kidonya.

The Istanbul Bulgarians, who learned, albeit late, of the arrest of their religious leaders, gathered on the initiative of Eftim Sapunov, the head of the aba-makers' guild, formed a group of 12 people and went to the Patriarchate in order to rescue Neofit and Ilarion. As they began to force the door of the place where Ilarion and Neofit were confined, they were compelled to turn back upon the intervention of gendarmes summoned by the Patriarchate's kavasses, who came from a nearby village. Realizing the seriousness of the situation, the Patriarchate sent the two prisoners to Mount Athos the next morning on a coal barge, and informed the Ottoman Government that it had done so on the basis of the authority granted to it by previous sultans. Although the Bulgarians in Istanbul, on Mount Athos and in the provinces of Bulgaria made extraordinary efforts to rescue these two leaders, this attempt remained fruitless owing above all to the opposition of the Russian envoy in Istanbul, Titov, who believed the intrigues contrived beforehand by the Patriarchate.

Meanwhile, during Sultan Abdülmecid's journey to Bulgaria, the Bulgarians of Svishtov, Stara Zagora, Kazanlak and Gabrovo complained to him of the injustice and oppression of the Greek religious leaders and pleaded for the release of Neofit Bozveli and Ilarion Makariopolski. The Sultan, who arrived in Tarnovo on 15 May 1846, met with the same complaints there and ordered the necessary measures to be taken. On 27 May 1846 they submitted to the Sultan, who had passed from Tarnovo to Ruse, a petition containing the following points:

1 - That the annual salaries of the bishops be determined and their servants be fixed;

2 - That bishops be elected by the people;

3 - That the Bulgarians be granted permission to have their own bishops;

4 - That bishops not be allowed to load onto the people debts unknown to the people;

5 - That the Ottoman administration disregard the Patriarchate's excuses that it did not permit the appointment of Bulgarian bishops because it had no confidence in them;

6 - That the Patriarchate be prevented from rejecting, each time the Bulgarians asked for any Bulgarian to be appointed bishop, such an appointment by claiming that they were troublemakers. This petition was presented to Sultan Abdülmecid in the presence of Grand Vizier Mustafa Reşid Pasha, of General Nayden Gerov, who had been sent to Ruse by the Russian Tsar Nicholas I to greet the Sultan, and of the Serbian Prince Aleksandar Karađorđević. Nevertheless, the Patriarchate, being informed of the situation, convinced the Sublime Porte that all this was a plot by the Bulgarians who wished to escape the supervision of the Greek bishops controlling them, and consequently the Bulgarians' initiative also came to nothing. Meanwhile Neofit Bozveli died on Mount Athos (4 July 1848). Ilarion was pardoned and came to Istanbul (28 November 1850).