While Wrangel, condemned to mark time with an army of thirty thousand men thirsting for blood and plunder in the face of four hundred rifles, floundered in indecision at the foot of Mount Gunib, the Russian commander-in-chief, Prince Baryatinsky, accompanied by General Yevdokimov, his entire general staff and the commanders of many Russian combat units, continued his pompous journey and already regarded himself as the conqueror of Daghestan and Chechnya. It is a very sad event, both very hard and very bitter to believe, that on the second day after leaving Khunzakh the Russian commander-in-chief met and talked with Kabet Muhammad on these old roads of Shamil's victories and holy wars. That same Kabet Muhammad who had once been one of the most terrible and blessed storms to break over these luminous roads of victory and holy war, and perhaps the most terrible of all. That former hero, with the magnificent and avenging sword whose fame filled every corner of Tsarist Russia and with which for years he had driven and chased Russian generals before him, was today receiving one of those generals as a faded politician and a captive brought to his knees, and, as if this were not enough, was inviting to his house in Tilit the most sinful Russian commander-in-chief, who had dealt the heaviest and final death blow to the Caucasian national struggle. Prince Baryatinsky eagerly accepted this invitation, and during this visit, which in all probability had itself been encouraged and arranged by the Russian High Command, Kabet Muhammad, by giving a sumptuous luncheon banquet in the commander-in-chief's honor, lost both this world and the next and drew a pitch-black line through the great epic of victory and honor he had written over twenty-five years. The Russian commander-in-chief, who had lunched at Kabet Muhammad's house in Tilit, spent the following night, that of 18 August, among his army, which had set up a tented camp at the foot of Mount Chemodan. Shamil had set up his headquarters in the middle of the plateau right on top of Mount Gunib. This position lay at a highly commanding point that overlooked the Kara Koysu valley virtually from a bird's-eye view, and formed a narrow, pointed promontory like the beak of a terrible eagle. The Russian commander-in-chief, massing all the technical and modern means of the Russian army, secured to the utmost the possibilities of climbing and surmounting the slopes of Gunib, and hurled his choicest mountain troops at this sheer mountain in endless waves.
To repel the Russian assaults, Shamil could set no more than forty rifles against each battalion. The Russian infantry, attacking the mountain on three fronts, advanced in no fewer than ten columns, and in each assault column at least one or more infantry battalions were on the move. A climbing network consisting of hundreds of rope ladders and iron stakes had been woven over the sheer slopes from top to bottom. Shamil at once finished off those of these battalions, which attacked like packs of hungry wolves and advanced step by step, who managed to get near the top of the mountain, and with swords that could not be contained in their scabbards he dealt with those who in confusion set foot on the plateau where he had set up his headquarters. The Russian High Command was extremely impatient to convey to Tsar Alexander II as soon as possible the news of the greatest victory in the Caucasus, and was straining to win the honor that had fallen to no Russian command and to be able to say "I have taken Shamil prisoner!" But Prince Baryatinsky, who knew very well that he could reach the highest rung of military fame on the day he seized the terrible eagle's nest on the summit of Gunib, resorted to his artillery once he was convinced that it, raising its head to God and becoming ever more monumental the more it was pressed, could not easily be taken. Batteries of every kind, heavy and light, and mountain guns turned their hellish breath on the defenders of Gunib. The eyes of the nineteenth-century world were wide open and fixed upon the great and matchless lion of Daghestan, who stood alone on the summit of Mount Gunib against the mightiest invading armies of the Tsar.
The commander-in-chief, Prince Baryatinsky, bitterly realizing that there would be no possibility of capturing Shamil alive, and seeing that although he had paralyzed all of Gunib's means of defense and fortifications with a merciless artillery bombardment, the terrible defense continuing in the ruins of this fortress still showed no sign of collapsing, was compelled to resort to a final political measure. Prince Baryatinsky sent Danyal Sultan to Shamil with very great promises and guarantees of pardon in the name of Tsar Alexander II. Danyal Sultan implored Shamil: "O Imam, you see that all means of defense around you have been destroyed. The defenders of Gunib have been martyred to a man. At least do not let the lives of the women, the children and the old be taken. The Russian commander-in-chief promises, in the name of the Tsar and upon his military honor, that he will not let a speck of dust fall upon your great honor and glory. The Russian army will give way to you together with your children, your women and the loyal men you wish to take in your retinue. You will be free and at liberty to go to whatever country you wish. Come, do not reject this very favorable offer, do not trample on this last opportunity that has come to your feet." Shamil answered as if reciting the verses of war from the Holy Qur'an: "Until this soul leaves this body, Shamil does not surrender." Prince Baryatinsky, while giving his army the order for the final assault in the face of this answer from Shamil, could not help bowing in admiration before the greatness of the lion of Daghestan, beating his wings at dizzying heights that no human strength could approach. The fortress defenders around Shamil, together with all his relatives and children, did not exceed a hundred people. Hunger had reached its utmost limit.
These heroes of endurance, who had bound stones to their bellies, emptied their weapons to the very last shot without blinking an eye and awaited death eagerly, with the longing one feels for a beloved. The old men of Gunib, keeping their loyalty around Shamil to the last minute, spent all their efforts. When Shamil was at last compelled to bow his head before these pitiful cries and resign himself to fate, he announced that he left everyone free in their actions and decided, rather than surrender, to summon with his own hand the death that never dared to approach him and to throw himself into the arms of an honorable death. Prince Baryatinsky, commander-in-chief of the Caucasian armies and governor-general of the Caucasus, who through the last successes he had won in the Caucasus had become Russia's number one hero, left no measure untried to take Shamil without a hair of his head being harmed, and shrank from no material or moral sacrifice to attain this desire. Even the last defenders of Gunib, who had fallen into deep despair because all the pleas and interventions they had made to dissuade Shamil from this unshakable obstinacy and perseverance, and above all to prevent him from taking his own life, had met with no favor from the Imam, came to regard Shamil's falling alive into the hands of the Russian High Command as virtually a gain, and some were even seen acting as guides to the enemy, as it were, so that Prince Baryatinsky's mountaineer detachments could pass along these secret paths in order to bring this about. Shamil, who, besides being a great soldier and a great statesman of world stature in the affairs of war and of the world, also carried great fame and authority by virtue of his broad religious knowledge and sound learning, put this to these men as his first word: he asked them how they could guarantee that, should he accept the surrender being offered to him, he would not be held responsible and sinful tomorrow in the presence of God.
Although the ulema and the elders spent all their knowledge and strength trying to produce convincing answers to this hard question of Shamil's, the Imam, not content with these answers, proposed that they jointly discharge before Almighty God the heavy responsibility laid upon his own shoulders, and said: "Will you issue a fatwa to confirm these claims of yours and sign it in your own hand?" According to the Imam's very honorable terms of surrender, the Russian commander-in-chief would give him passage to leave Gunib with his children, his family and his loyal and veteran men, forty in number, and to go freely to Turkey, and the weapons neither of himself nor of the members of his retinue would ever be touched. About forty-eight hours passed before Shamil gathered his retinue and set out for the headquarters of the Russian High Command. Using this entirely natural delay as a pretext, Baryatinsky, who had promised with a soldier's word that he would accept without conditions, went back on his word, and when Shamil arrived at his headquarters he felt neither hesitation nor shame in informing him that he was an honored guest of the Tsar, but a prisoner.
At the time of Shamil's surrender, as he approached the Russian general headquarters with heavy and hesitant steps, accompanied by his sons Ghazi Muhammad and Muhammad Shafi and his guards, while the guard of honor came to the salute with a swift movement, all the Russian soldiers, who had come to admire Shamil in his absence as they heard again and again of his unbelievable deeds, were seized with great emotion before the majesty and grandeur of that great lion of Daghestan who knew no defeat, and made the forest ring with cries of hurrah. After passing with great dignity and composure before the Russian soldiers saluting him, Shamil saw that a number of Russian generals in full-dress uniform, wearing all their decorations, and a large body of officers were waiting for him right on the road he was walking. All of them had fixed their eyes, with great attention and emotion, on the genius leader who for thirty years had fought against the Russian armies with a heroism and skill that astonished the annals of war. It was decided that Shamil and the forty or so armed men of his retinue would keep their swords and daggers and be transferred at once to Temir-Khan-Shura, the general headquarters of the Russian High Command, and there the large building directly opposite the commander-in-chief's office was assigned as Shamil's residence.
