In short, the Turkish regime represented a strong, impartial central administration respectful of the rights of the native population, which took the peasant under effective protection against the feudalization seen in the last period of Byzantium and, after the break-up of Stefan Dušan's Empire, in most of the Balkans and in the Greek lands under Frankish rule, together with the security it brought. In the Balkan feudal world it is generally seen that state power to a certain extent disappeared, leaving its place to the ramification and intertwining of the seigneurs. By contrast, the Ottoman sultan, with the assistance of the grand vizier and the divan, stood at the top of an administrative pyramid that extended its roots to every corner of the empire. He kept under control the executors of central power, that is, the ehl-i örf, and the representatives of judicial power. The Ottoman state displayed a series of features not present in the feudal system. The most important characteristics that must be pointed out are that the right to benefit from timars was transferred only in return for service, and that this right was established not over the farmers themselves but over the financial dues that the reaya owed to the state.
The system of conquest employed by the Turks who established this order of administration, whose features we have briefly explained, was to take over the principalities in neighbouring states and settle there, and then to establish control over those regions by gradually eliminating the native dynasties. This does not mean that the population living in that region was assimilated, or that their identities were destroyed by converting them. Those who were eliminated were the feudal rulers. The advanced order of Turkish administration had positive effects on the living conditions of the settled population there. In this respect too, the role of the timar system is great. While the timar system influenced the native population on the one hand, on the other hand, because it brought central authority, it also facilitated Turkish migration. Indeed, Turkification is greater in the regions where the timar system was applied than in the regions where it was not. We can list examples of this two-way development as follows:
When we examine the Survey Register of Shkodra dated 1485 (Defter-i Mufassal-ı Liva-i İskenderiye), published in Tirana in 1974 by Selami Pulaha, an Albanian historian, the first point that strikes the eye is that place and personal names have preserved their originality. For example, on page 5 of volume II, eight places of religious worship are seen. Of these, five are monasteries, two are churches and one is a hermitage. In the nahiye of İpek (Peć) there is one Muslim and six non-Muslim quarters. In the villages of the same nahiye, too, it is seen that the majority of the population consists of non-Muslims. In the nahiye of İpek there are monasteries that are centres of settlement. The names of some of these monasteries, which number about ten, are as follows: Manastır-ı İstasi, Manastır-ı Şumti Bogovaç, Manastır-ı Nikola. The same picture is seen in Karye-i Komnende on page 30 of the work. In the nahiye of Kumaron on page 36 there is also a monastery.
The examples in this register are clear proof that the Ottomans left the population of the regions they conquered free in terms of language, religion and race. The fact that there are many non-Muslims in these registers, which actually belong to Albania, stems from the register belonging to the early periods. For the Ottomans set certain criteria to encourage Islam. In order for the native population to attain certain posts, to enter the military cadre or to attain certain offices, they had to be Muslim. This being so, a considerable degree of Islamization is seen without compulsion, especially in certain regions such as Albania and Bosnia. However, although the Albanians and Bosniaks accepted Islam, there was no change in their nationality. That is, they did not become Turkified. Indeed, the Albanian historian Selami Pulaha clearly expresses this point in many of his studies.
The Survey Register of Buda from the Reign of Süleyman the Magnificent (1546–1562), published in 1971 by Dr. Gyula Káldy-Nagy, makes it possible to get to know Turkish rule in Hungary more closely. Under the heading "Nahiye-i Budun der liva-i Paşa" it is seen that a large part of the personal names and quarters in Nefs-i Budun (the town of Buda proper) consisted of non-Muslims. Whereas, according to the Sofia Survey Register, which we shall discuss later, the majority of the population in the city of Sofia were Muslim Turks. Indeed, as is also stated in the preface of the register, it is seen that some Hungarian words are used in the register. For example, biro = headman, diak = scribe, varos = town... and so on.
The Detailed Survey Register of the Sanjak of Srem (Sirem), published in 1983 by Bruce W. McGowan, provides extensive information on how Srem was governed in the Ottoman period. The document contains quite interesting records concerning the conquest policies of the Turks. The point that interests us here is the most distinctive Ottoman policy of conquest and settlement: the method of bringing a region under central administration in stages.
Since the inhabitants of the sanjak of Srem were Serbs, most of the place and personal names are Slavic. In the sanjak of Srem too, a large part of the names of nahiyes and villages are a continuation of old place names and, as the publisher also points out, most of them are Slavic. Here there are settlements such as Manastır-ı İstari and Kızıl Kilise. The town of Ilok in the sanjak, as the urban centre, consists mostly of Muslim Turks; however, non-Muslim names are also encountered, albeit in small numbers. Of the villages of the same kaza, two are Muslim Turkish, 37 non-Muslim and three mixed. In some of the villages that are not Muslim Turkish there are one or two Muslim Turkish households. The situation of the other kazas of the sanjak of Srem, which has many kazas, is also similar to that of Ilok.
The examples we have listed so far are proof that, while establishing their dominion in the Balkans, the Ottomans did not pursue a systematic policy of conversion, that is, of Islamization, as some present-day historians claim. Indeed, Machiel Kiel, a Western historian of the Ottomans, fully supports these views in his work Art and Society of Bulgaria in the Turkish Period, published in 1985. In any case, there could be no question of their turning to a course of action that would require such compulsion. Namely:
1. The Ottoman state, like most Middle Eastern Empires, had based on Islamic theory a conception of government nourished by a number of sources and influenced especially by the old Turkish tradition. Although Islamic law, fiqh, essentially laid down rules regulating the relations of Muslims, it had also determined what principles non-Muslims would be subject to when, if they recognized the authority of the Islamic caliph, they were taken into the status of dhimmi. From the point of view of administration, their being non-Muslims did not create any difficulty. For that reason, an invitation to Islam or a spontaneous coming to the true path was regarded only as a phenomenon met with joy, and such new brothers in religion were well received.
2. As I explained a little earlier, in the conquest of the Balkans the Ottomans had made use of the driving force of the "uç" (frontier) tradition. The tolerant, eclectic characteristics of frontier life led to a more tolerant attitude than in the hinterland towards the non-Muslims, who were called dhimmis and taken under the protection of the sultan.
3. Moreover, since the jizya, the canonical tax collected from non-Muslims, was a cash tax, these revenues were of a kind that could be transferred directly to the central treasury, so from this point of view too there could be no question of the state applying a policy of forced Islamization.
4. Because the conquered countries, again from the point of view of Islamic theory, turned into dârü'l-İslâm, Islamic land, these places also became open to settlement by a Turkish-Islamic population. Indeed, it is possible to list abundant evidence of this second aspect of the development:
The flow of Turkish-Islamic population into the conquered regions took place mainly in the following ways:
1. We see that from the moment the Ottomans crossed into the Balkans and began to advance, the Turkmens too began to settle there. As this proceeded, the numbers and importance of the Turkmen groups increased accordingly, and later the need arose to attach them to a military organization and to create a special order and law for them. It is possible to find the proofs of this fact both in the chronicles and in the survey registers. For example, Aşıkpaşazâde records that as early as 1335 "the nomad households that came to the province of Karesi were transferred to Rumelia, and they resided for a while in the vicinity of Gallipoli", and adds that they went to Hayrabolu, settled there and engaged in gaza. We see this in all regions of the Balkans in the later phases of the conquest.
After they had spread completely across Rumelia, in order to facilitate their registration and their being placed under obligations, the Turkmens were named either after the locality and centre where they were concentrated, or after some characteristic of theirs, or after the name of the person who headed that community, and were known in this way in official transactions. On the other hand, separate registers were drawn up for each of these Turkmen groups; one copy of each was sent to the centre, and the other copies were given to the Turkmen beys. These registers, which were constantly consulted and copies of which were made and sent to the persons concerned when necessary, were renewed from time to time, and new surveys were made to reflect new situations fully and accurately.
