Philosophy and Science

In the end Sufism ceased to be a religious-intellectual impulse and became the scene of a number of irrational practices such as discovering the future, lifting the "veil of mystery" and soothsaying, and miracles (keramet) came to be expected of every sheikh and dervish. This situation, in turn, distanced from the scientific mentality and from the truth the masses whom it deprived of the faculty of positive thinking and whose sound religious upbringing it at the same time corrupted; moreover, the quarrels that went on between the madrasa, which increasingly rendered religious knowledge rigid, and the dervish lodge (the seat of the Sufi order), virtually exhausted the rational thought and scientific life of the earlier centuries.

In this respect, it is necessary to treat the subject of positive science in the history of the Islamic-Turkish states in two periods. In the first period, up to the middle of the 12th century, science, which, as seen in philosophy, displayed a power capable of guiding the world, seems afterwards to have faded away.

In the Turkish-Islamic communities, positive science again begins with al-Farabi. The Latin translation of the work Ihsa' al-'Ulum (Enumeration of the Sciences), with which al-Farabi was the first to classify the sciences, served as the basis for the book of Gundissalinus (d. 1157) on the same subject. Al-Farabi also wrote a commentary on the geometry of Euclid. Among other scholars, mention must be made here of Abdullah al-Bârânî (d. 929), of Turkish origin, considered one of the founders of trigonometry, and of Ibn Turk al-Jili, author of the Kitab al-Jabr wa'l-Muqabala, one of the principal representatives of mathematics in the East. One of the mathematical scholars was Abu Rayhan al-Biruni of Khwarazm (d. 1051).

It is noteworthy that al-Biruni, who lived at the Turkish court of Ghazna and took part in the Indian campaigns alongside Sultan Mahmud, and who was probably of Turkish origin, cites Qur'anic "verses" together with the words of Greek philosophers in his works. According to him, freedom of thought is a precondition for the progress of science, and "The thoughts and beliefs of human beings differ from one another. Civilization (mâmuriyet) is born of this diversity". Al-Biruni, who with his open mind appears as a scientist of a modern character, wrote more than 110 works in various branches of knowledge. In his work Istikhraj al-Awtar fi'l-Da'ira he set out new theorems on arcs and chords of the circle, and in his Tasdiq al-Suwar he examined methods of geometric projection.

His discoveries concerning a classical problem of geometry that cannot be solved using compass and straightedge alone are still referred to as the "Biruni Problems". His book Tahdid Nihayat al-Amakin, on the other hand, concerns the study of mathematical geography, and some trigonometric problems are also explained in it. Al-Biruni is regarded as "one of the scientific and intellectual geniuses of world history of the type of Archimedes, Leonardo and Leibniz".

According to al-Farabi, who explained the groundlessness of efforts in astronomy to derive judgments about the future from the stars (ilm-i Nücum, astrology), it is not possible to discover the destinies of human beings from celestial beings and phenomena: to believe that a celestial phenomenon such as a solar eclipse, which occurs when the moon comes between the earth and the sun, has a connection with, for example, the death of a ruler on earth is "acab al-acaib" (the absurdest of absurdities). According to al-Farabi, every phenomenon has a cause: "Chance events are phenomena whose cause we do not know".

Ibn Sina (Avicenna) worked at the Hamadan observatory, while al-Biruni spoke in his Tarikh al-Hind of the earth revolving around the sun in one year; in his al-Qanun al-Mas'udi (written in the name of the Ghaznavid Sultan Mas'ud I) he dwelt on latitudes and longitudes and determined the dimensions of the earth and the circles of latitude and longitude between Ghazna and Alexandria. After Ibn Sina, who stated that he did not believe in the "Philosopher's stone", claimed to turn every metal it touched into gold, or in the "Elixir" that prolongs life or makes it eternal, and that these were mere fantasies, al-Biruni again, in his work al-Jamahir fi Ma'rifat al-Jawahir, reached important results for the first time on the subject of specific gravity, and with a pycnometer he invented he measured the specific gravity of 16 substances very close to the true values.