KEMAL BEY, NATIONAL MARTYR
Yet the heavy pressure of the French and British occupation commanders, the Armenian komitadjis and the Armenian Patriarch Zaven for Kemal Bey to be hanged at all costs continued.
Thereupon the President of the court-martial, Hayret Pasha, after a heated argument with Grand Vizier Ferid Pasha, submitted his resignation.
In his place Kurdish Mustafa Pasha, known by the nickname "Nemrud", was appointed.
THE VERDICT
The court now ceased to be a court and became a body charged with carrying out an order given in advance.
To Nemrud Mustafa Pasha as well, Kemal Bey said:
"I received orders. An official is obliged to obey the orders he receives. I treated those who were removed from the town as deportees in the most humane way. Indeed, even now I feel no pangs of conscience."
Nemrud Mustafa, rising from his seat, shouted at Kemal Bey:
"When you drove so many people, with their women and children, into the mountains and high pastures in the dead of winter, did you have no fear of God? Did you not think that one day you would be called to account for them? And on top of that you ordered the gendarmes to bayonet them; what do you say?"
"No, I will never accept that. I am not a man who ever gave an order for anyone's death."
"Is making thousands of wretched people, women and children alike, march on mountaintops in the cold of this God-given winter somehow better than bayoneting them? Moreover, you are an administrative chief; they were placed under your protection."
Then, raising his voice still further, he asked:
"Do you know what the punishment is for setting one group of citizens living within our country against another and inciting attacks on life and property?"
"It is death, Pasha..."
"You have pronounced your own sentence with your own mouth, Kemal Bey; we too had reached this decision about you."
The Gendarmerie Commander, Major Tevfik Bey, was sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment.
THE EXECUTION
Indeed, the death sentence had already been prepared in advance. As soon as the trial ended, the ready verdict was sent to the Palace for ratification. However, there were those who suspected that the Padishah would hesitate on this matter. They were the Minister of the Interior Mehmed Ali Bey and Said Molla, Undersecretary of Justice and President of the Society of Friends of England.
These two men hurriedly sent Damad Ferid Pasha to the palace.
Sultan Vahideddin asked the Şeyhülislam for a fatwa for the ratification of the verdict. The Şeyhülislam Mustafa Sabri Efendi avoided issuing a fatwa, giving the opinion that "what is requested regarding Kemal Bey is not a fatwa. It pertains to 'kaza' (jurisdiction), and I have no authority over kaza." When the Padishah insisted, he stated in general terms that "the death penalty is permissible when a Muslim kills a non-Muslim, but for this ruling to be given, it is a condition that the person killed was wounded with a wounding instrument and died of it, and that his heirs thereupon demand 'kısas' (retaliation)." But he did not neglect to add a note to satisfy the Padishah. In this note it was explained that, provided the trial of Kemal Bey, sentenced to death by the Martial Court-Martial (Divan-ı Harb-i Örfi), had been conducted in accordance with right and justice, the death sentence was appropriate.
