The Mongol-Turkic System of Administration
Talk of the "Tatar yoke" has become so fashionable in Russian history that even Soviet Russian historians took up the expression again. Undoubtedly, the rule of a foreign group, especially of a people entirely different in race and religion, is no easy thing. However, considering that as a result of 240 years of Golden Horde rule the Russians not only preserved their language, religion, lands and administrative organization completely, but even succeeded in strengthening all of these, it becomes clear that this Tatar rule was not a "yoke". Not only under a foreign group but even under normal government administration, when a rebellion breaks out it is suppressed at once and force is used for this purpose, and, as the case may be, thousands of people are killed; when obligations are not fulfilled, compulsion is used to enforce them by force and violence. It is a historical fact that the baskaks and darughas of the Golden Horde acted no differently. There is not the slightest doubt that the rule of the Golden Horde over the Russian principalities was many times milder than the rule of the later Russian tsars in Kazan, Bashkiria, Sibir, Crimea, the Caucasus and Turkestan. It is certain that not even a tenth of the measures taken by Ivan the Terrible and by the tsarist governments of the Romanov family to annihilate the Turkic peoples were ever taken by the khans of the Golden Horde. Some of the pressure and violence applied to the Russian princes stemmed rather from the intrigues the Russians themselves conducted at Saray, at the court of the khans. As required by the tradition of the Mongol-Turkic state, there was complete religious and linguistic tolerance in the Golden Horde.
The subject peoples, once they had duly fulfilled their obligations, which were not very heavy, were not subjected to needless pressure. Thanks to the "yarliks" granted by the khans of the Golden Horde, the Russian Church had gained tarkhan status, that is, it had been exempted from all kinds of taxes and obligations; in spite of this, it was above all the Church that later nourished the Russian policy of annihilation against the Tatars.
Among the effects of two and a half centuries of Tatar rule, the khans of the Golden Horde were regarded by the Russian population as true sovereigns; this is why the Russian princes dared to assume the title of "Tsar" only after they had freed themselves from Golden Horde rule.
The forces that carried out the conquests under the command of Batu Khan are said to have numbered 600,000 men: of these only 60,000 were Mongols; the rest had been gathered from various Turkic peoples; Mongols stood at the head of the command staff and of certain offices.
The origin of the name Tatar must be Turkic. It is for this reason that the Europeans called all the forces that carried out the Mongol invasion "Tatars", without distinguishing between Mongols and Turks. For this reason, too, the Turkic peoples in Genghis's armies came to appear as such in the eyes of foreigners, even if they did not call themselves by that name. Although the Mongols who settled along the Itil (Volga) were before long absorbed among the numerous Turkic element, the population of this region, despite being Turkic, came to be known by the name "Tatar". As a result of the Mongol invasion, the Turkic element in the Idel-Ural region and Siberia increased, and to a certain extent the Mongol element also mixed with the local population; but it appears that this group belonged mostly to the upper class.