FROM THE KIZILELMA IDEAL TO THE REALITY OF TURAN
Influential Orientalists such as the missionary Ilminsky and Professor Smirnov, who were regarded as experts on Russia's Muslim and Turkic subjects, said that allowing the newspaper to be published had been a political mistake. On the other hand, a report of the Russian secret police, the Okhrana, stated that the Islamic propaganda seen in this newspaper and in other Turkic newspapers following the same path was a curtain concealing Pan-Turkism.
Gaspıralı İsmail Bey continued to publish his newspaper by selling his wife's jewellery and the furnishings of his house. Although there were many attempts to have Tercüman closed down, İsmail Bey's intelligence, skill and energy countered the intrigues of all the enemies of the Turks and of Islam and secured the continued publication of this tiny weekly, the only newspaper appearing in the language of a Turkic mass of twenty to thirty million people.
His synthesis, which consisted of holding fast to Turkdom and Islam while adopting the science and technology of the West, and his other ideas influenced not only the Turks of Turkey but also the Turks of the Crimea, Kazan, Azerbaijan and Turkestan.
Many Turkists and Turanists who followed İsmail Bey came forth: Yusuf Akçura, Hüseyinzade Ali Bey, Ağaoğlu Ahmet Bey, Sadri Maksudi (Arsal), Zeki Velidi (Togan), Abdullah Battal (Taymas), and many other thinkers and men of action. After the Russo-Japanese War of 1905, Russia had become a cauldron of ideologies. During this turmoil, which lasted until 1917, the Turks unfortunately achieved nothing. The work in the Duma (the Russian parliament) and in the congresses remained fruitless. The decisions taken at these congresses, held with representatives sent by the Turkic and Muslim communities from all over Russia, could not be put into practice. The somewhat tribalistic behaviour of the Turkic communities prevented them from founding the Great Turan. Especially during the collapse of the Russian Tsardom, no agreement could be reached on the path to be followed. Some favoured autonomy, others federation; a senseless local nationalism was pursued. The efforts made with a Turanist outlook by the Turks of the Crimea and Kazan, with Gaspıralı İsmail Bey at their head, and by the Turks of Azerbaijan remained fruitless.
In his article entitled "What Should the Turks of Russia Do?", written in 1918 in Yeni Mecmua, Gökalp said that "tribal consciousness" was a pathological phenomenon and that it should be abandoned and replaced by "national consciousness". But it was already too late. Although in Central Asia the newspapers Birlik Tuvı, Uluğ Türkistan, Türk Söz, El Bayrağı, Turan and Hürriyet began to cultivate the idea of All-Turkdom and the "Great Turan", the Russians occupied the Turkic lands one by one, and Enver Pasha and his Basmachis were destroyed. These ideas could not be killed; they were merely prevented from coming to the surface by very harsh measures. Cholpan's poems are still remembered. The hope of them all is that the Turkdom of Anatolia will one day reach the Kızılelma and found the Great Turan.
From the 1908s onward, Turkism, which developed steadily around the Türk Derneği, the Türk Ocağı and Türk Yurdu, was systematized by Ziya Gökalp. Prof. Zeki Velidi Togan says, "We must accept Ziya Gökalp as the spiritual guide of Turkism," and adds the following: "If there are errors and shortcomings, we must complete them. It would be beneficial to carry forward the Turkism developed by Gökalp on its cultural foundations and to keep it away from politics. However, the liberation and unity of the Turkic world must also live in hearts as an ideal," just like the Kızılelma Ideal and the reality of the Great Turan.
The Great Turan State was founded by Oghuz Khan. Those who came after him tried to keep this lofty state standing under various dynastic names. In the Huns, Göktürks, Uyghurs, Avars, Khazars, Pechenegs, Cumans, Karakhanids, Ghaznavids, Seljuks, Ottomans and dozens more great Turanian world states, the single fixed, unchanging element is the Nation, that is, the Turkish Nation, and naturally the fact that their language is Turkish. The names of states and dynasties have come and gone and changed; and in any case this is of no importance.
What is essential is the Nation and the ideal that brings it into being. Our purpose in giving the name Turkish-Turanian History to the great work of the nature of a General Turkish History presented on this site is this:
It was to emphasize that Turkish history and the Turkish nation are a single whole; that there is no difference in essence between a soldier of Oghuz Khan five thousand years ago and a Turkish soldier or an ordinary person of the people today; and that what could make him different would be his having lost the Kızılelma in his heart or having cast the idea of the Great Turan out of his mind.
With the Kızılelma ideal in our hearts and the idea of the Great Turan in our minds, from Northern Siberia to Manchuria, or from an American Indian chief of Turanian lineage at the far end of America to an Anatolian Turkish sheikh effendi left behind in the lands of Yemen who stubbornly insists on speaking Turkish, we are a great, a very great nation.
And when one speaks of the Great Turan State, what should be understood is the place where this great Nation dwells, and its heart. End
