With the transfer of the capital to Saray, the city of Bulgar was used until the second half of the 14th century as a summer resort where the Golden Horde khans spent their summers. The Kipchaks had reached Volga Bulgaria between the 11th and 13th centuries and served in the Bulgar army. However, after the founding of the Golden Horde, the Kipchaks poured into the Volga region in large groups. But in the 13th–14th centuries the Kipchaks did not find much of a place for themselves in the Bulgar bureaucracy. This can be seen clearly from the gravestones uncovered in the region as well. Of the two hundred gravestones that have survived from this period to our day, 90% were written in Bulgar (today's Chuvash, rhotacism) and the remaining 10% in Kipchak (today's Tatar, zetacism). During the raids of Pulat Timur, mentioned above, of Timur and of the Russians, the Bulgar Chuvash crossed to the left bank of the Chulman-Idel, while some settled in the central regions and in the north of present-day Chuvashia along the Volga; the people on the right bank of the Volga moved from the present Ulyanovsk (Simbirsk) region to the southern regions of present-day Tatarstan, and from the southern and southeastern regions of present-day Chuvashia to the lower reaches and the northeast of the Sviyaga river. At the beginning of the 15th century the Mongol-Tatars brought four-fifths of all the Bulgar-Chuvash under their rule.
After the founding of the Kazan Khanate in place of the Golden Horde, which collapsed in the first half of the 15th century, the Kipchak-Tatars began once again to come to the Volga region in large groups. Ulugh Muhammad Khan, who founded the Kazan Khanate, also brought with him to Kazan an army of three thousand Tatars. As a result, intensive Tatar migrations to Kazan began from the center of the Golden Horde, from the Azov area, from Astrakhan and from Crimea. The Kazan Khanate, having brought the Finno-Ugric tribes and the Bulgar-Chuvash of the region under its rule, completed its development.
One branch of the Mishar Tatars of the Volga region is, as stated in written sources, a part of the Finno-Ugrians who lived in the Qasim Khanate that ruled in Meshchera in the 15th–16th centuries (the majority of the Meshchera have become Russified), who became Tatarized by mixing with the Kipchak-Tatars who came from the Golden Horde.
The first stage in the acquisition of national identity by the present-day Chuvash is the period of the Volga Bulgar State. In this period we see that the various Finno-Ugric peoples living in the region mixed with the Bulgar-Suvars and were assimilated. The population of the Bulgar State living mostly in the cities became Muslim, while the majority of the population living in the countryside and in the villages continued their old beliefs. But this Shamanism changed under the influence of Islam and came closer to Islam. The establishment of belief in one God, and concepts such as paradise, hell, halal, haram, fate, Satan, prophet and sin, entered Chuvash Shamanism under the influence of Islam. The Bulgar State had various struggles with this non-Muslim population. The majority of the Bulgars who accepted Islam in time mixed with the Kipchaks and became Tatarized. During the period of the Kazan Khanate too, as a result of increasing religious pressure, the non-Muslim Chuvash came together once again with the Finno-Ugric tribes. This is the second stage in the acquisition of national identity by the Chuvash.
